Applebee's vs Chili's Grill & Bar: Which Is Actually Healthier?

It’s a classic American dilemma. You’re looking for a reliable, sit-down meal that satisfies everyone from picky kids to hungry adults. The two heavyweight champions of casual dining immediately come to mind: Applebee’s and Chili’s. Both offer a familiar comfort, a lively atmosphere, and menus packed with burgers, ribs, salads, and sizzling entrees. But when you’re trying to stick to your health goals, the choice becomes more complicated.

These chains are so similar that their nutritional profiles must be identical, right? Not so fast. We sent both menus to the Snackly lab, ran the numbers, and calculated a Coach Score for a dozen popular items from each restaurant. In this head-to-head matchup, we’ll break down the data to declare a definitive winner in the battle for the healthier menu.

The Matchup

Applebee’s and Chili’s occupy the same space in our collective consciousness: the go-to neighborhood grill and bar. They are the backdrop for countless first dates, family celebrations, and post-work happy hours. Both menus are built on a foundation of American classics—burgers, steaks, chicken, and ribs—with a Tex-Mex and Southwestern flair woven throughout. The question isn't just about which tastes better, but which one makes it easier to eat better. Let the games begin.

Tale of the Tape

Before we dive into specific dishes, let's look at the big picture. We analyzed 12 popular items from Applebee's and 11 from Chili's, calculating a Snackly Coach Score for each. The Coach Score (0-100) provides a holistic view of an item's healthiness, factoring in calories, protein, carbs, fat, fiber, and other nutritional data points.

At first glance, this fight is incredibly close—a virtual dead heat. Applebee's squeaks by with a slightly higher average Coach Score, suggesting a menu that might be, on the whole, a tiny bit safer if you’re ordering blind. However, this average doesn't tell the whole story. As we’ll see, Chili’s boasts the single healthiest item on our list, while also harboring some of the most catastrophic calorie bombs. This data suggests that while both chains require careful navigation, Chili’s offers higher highs and lower lows, making informed ordering absolutely critical.

Best Overall Order at Each

If you want to walk into either restaurant and place the single best order for your health, these are your picks. We’re looking for the highest Coach Score, which represents the best balance of low calories, high protein, and overall nutritional quality.

Applebee's Best: Grilled Chicken Breast

* Nutrition: 390 calories, 44g protein, 20g carbs, 14g fat, 4g fiber

* Coach Score: 58/100

This dish is a lean, mean, protein-packing machine. At under 400 calories, it delivers an impressive 44 grams of muscle-building protein with minimal carbs and fat. It's a clean, simple, and effective choice for anyone looking to fuel their body without derailing their diet.

Chili's Best: 6 oz Sirloin with Grilled Avocado

* Nutrition: 350 calories, 38g protein, 8g carbs, 18g fat, 4g fiber

* Coach Score: 61/100

Chili's comes out swinging with its top contender. This perfectly portioned sirloin is a nutritional knockout, clocking in at just 350 calories. It keeps carbs in the single digits while providing a satisfying 38 grams of protein and healthy fats from the grilled avocado. It’s a beautifully balanced meal that proves steak can absolutely be part of a healthy diet.

Round Winner: Chili's Grill & Bar

While Applebee's Grilled Chicken is an excellent choice, the Chili's 6 oz Sirloin takes the crown. It achieves a higher Coach Score by delivering a fantastic nutritional profile at an even lower calorie count, making it the undisputed champion of healthy entrees between the two.

Protein Showdown

For those focused on building muscle or maximizing satiety, protein is king. We looked for a high-protein entree from each menu that still maintained a respectable nutritional profile.

Applebee's Contender: Blackened Cajun Salmon

* Nutrition: 580 calories, 46g protein, 36g carbs, 26g fat, 6g fiber

* Coach Score: 51/100

While the Cedar Grilled Lemon Chicken offers a bit more protein (52g), the Blackened Cajun Salmon brings a more well-rounded profile with a higher Coach Score. It provides a hefty 46 grams of high-quality protein and 6 grams of fiber, along with the heart-healthy omega-3 fatty acids that salmon is famous for. It’s a flavorful and powerful choice.

Chili's Contender: Ancho Salmon

* Nutrition: 590 calories, 42g protein, 38g carbs, 28g fat, 6g fiber

* Coach Score: 47/100

Chili’s answers with its own salmon dish. The macros are strikingly similar to Applebee’s version, with nearly identical calories, carbs, and fat. However, it delivers slightly less protein for the same caloric price, which is reflected in its slightly lower Coach Score.

Round Winner: Applebee's

In this direct comparison of similar dishes, Applebee's takes the win. Its Blackened Cajun Salmon offers more protein and a better overall Coach Score than its Chili's counterpart, making it the superior choice for a protein-focused fish entree.

Best for Weight Loss / GLP-1

If you're managing your weight or following a GLP-1 lifestyle, you're looking for maximum satiety from the fewest calories. That means high protein, high fiber, and low overall energy density.

Applebee's Pick: Grilled Chicken Breast

* Nutrition: 390 calories, 44g protein, 20g carbs, 14g fat, 4g fiber

Making a return to the ring, the Grilled Chicken Breast is an ideal candidate. Its standout feature is the incredible protein-to-calorie ratio. Getting 44 grams of protein for under 400 calories is a huge win for staying full and satisfied long after your meal.

Chili's Pick: 6 oz Sirloin with Grilled Avocado

* Nutrition: 350 calories, 38g protein, 8g carbs, 18g fat, 4g fiber

The champion returns. Chili's best overall dish is also its best for weight management. At an astonishingly low 350 calories, it's one of the most diet-friendly steak dinners you'll find anywhere. The combination of high protein and healthy fats from the avocado promotes fullness, while the single-digit carb count prevents blood sugar spikes.

Round Winner: Chili's Grill & Bar

This is an incredibly close fight between two fantastic options. However, the Chili's Sirloin wins by a hair. Its ultra-low calorie count of 350 makes it exceptionally efficient for anyone in a calorie deficit, offering incredible flavor and satisfaction without the guilt.

Best for Low-Carb / Keto

For those following a ketogenic or low-carb diet, keeping carbohydrates to an absolute minimum is the top priority.

Applebee's Pick: Classic Wings (Bone-In, Traditional)

* Nutrition: 740 calories, 52g protein, 2g carbs, 58g fat, 0g fiber

If you're purely hunting for the lowest carb count, look no further. With a shockingly low 2 grams of carbs, these traditional bone-in wings (make sure to order them without a sugary sauce) are a keto dieter's dream. The trade-off is a very high fat and calorie count, making this more of a targeted indulgence than an everyday meal.

Chili's Pick: 6 oz Sirloin with Grilled Avocado

* Nutrition: 350 calories, 38g protein, 8g carbs, 18g fat, 4g fiber

Could it be a three-peat? Yes, it can. The 6 oz Sirloin is not only great for weight loss, but it's also a star for low-carb eating. With only 8 grams of carbs, it fits comfortably into most low-carb plans while providing a complete, balanced meal of protein, fat, and vegetables—something the wings can't claim.

Round Winner: Chili's Grill & Bar

While Applebee's wings are technically lower in carbs, Chili's Sirloin wins this round for being a superior *meal*. It delivers a fantastic low-carb experience in a nutritionally balanced package that won't blow your calorie or fat budget for the day. It’s the smarter, more sustainable choice.

Biggest Landmines

Every menu has them: dishes that sound tempting but pack a shocking amount of calories, fat, and sodium. These are the orders that can undo a week of healthy eating in a single sitting.

Applebee's Worst Offender: Quesadilla Burger

* Nutrition: 1090 calories, 54g protein, 56g carbs, 72g fat, 4g fiber

This Frankenstein's monster of a meal combines a burger and a quesadilla into one artery-clogging package. The 72 grams of fat are more than most people should consume in an entire day, and the 1090-calorie count is staggering. Also, beware of seemingly healthy options: the full-size Oriental Chicken Salad contains a surprising 790 calories and 40 grams of fat, mostly from the fried toppings and dressing.

Chili's Worst Offender: Big Mouth Crispy Chicken Sandwich

* Nutrition: 1340 calories, 46g protein, 100g carbs, 82g fat, 4g fiber

If you thought the Quesadilla Burger was bad, hold my beer. This sandwich is a nutritional catastrophe. At 1,340 calories and an unbelievable 82 grams of fat, it's one of the unhealthiest items you can order at any casual dining restaurant. The Cajun Chicken Pasta is just as bad, also clocking in at 1,340 calories with 78 grams of fat. These dishes are true diet destroyers.

Round Winner (for being worse): Chili's Grill & Bar

Applebee's has some definite landmines, but Chili's takes its calorie bombs to another level. With multiple entrees soaring past the 1,300-calorie mark, Chili's menu contains significantly more dangerous traps for the unsuspecting diner.

The Final Verdict

After a hard-fought battle, it's time to declare a winner. Based on the data, Chili's Grill & Bar is the healthier choice—*if* you order correctly.

While Applebee's has a slightly better average Coach Score, indicating a more consistent menu, Chili's offers the single best item by a significant margin. The 6 oz Sirloin with Grilled Avocado is a true nutritional superstar, winning our "Best Overall," "Best for Weight Loss," and "Best for Low-Carb" categories. Chili’s proves that it’s possible to eat an exceptionally healthy, low-calorie, high-protein meal at a casual dining chain. The massive caveat is that you must also navigate past its equally extreme high-calorie landmines, which are more numerous and more damaging than Applebee's worst offenders.

Applebee's is the runner-up, offering very solid healthy choices like the Grilled Chicken Breast and Blackened Cajun Salmon, but it lacks a true "best-in-class" standout like the Chili's sirloin.

FAQ

Q: So, is Applebee's or Chili's Grill & Bar healthier?

A: Chili's is healthier if you know what to order. It has the best healthy entree between the two (6 oz Sirloin with Grilled Avocado), but its unhealthiest items are far worse than Applebee's. If you’re using an app like Snackly to make an informed choice, Chili’s offers a higher ceiling for healthy eating.

Q: What's the healthiest thing at Applebee's?

A: The Grilled Chicken Breast is the top choice. With 390 calories and a massive 44 grams of protein, it's a lean, satisfying meal that supports nearly any health goal.

Q: What's the healthiest thing at Chili's Grill & Bar?

A: The 6 oz Sirloin with Grilled Avocado is the undisputed champion. At just 350 calories, 38g of protein, and 8g of carbs, it's one of the most nutritionally impressive entrees you can find in casual dining.

Q: Are salads always a healthy choice at these restaurants?

A: Absolutely not, and this is a common trap. For example, the Applebee's Oriental Chicken Salad has 790 calories and 40g of fat, which is more than their Classic Burger. Always check the nutrition on salads, as crispy toppings, cheese, and creamy dressings can quickly turn a healthy-sounding meal into a calorie bomb.

---

Scan either menu with Snackly — know before you eat. Download free on [App Store](#) and [Google Play](#).